In Canadian Chemistry Olympiad preparation, an endothermic reaction need not have a positive standard free-energy change at every temperature. The entropy term matters, and its units must match the enthalpy term. This independently written hypothetical model contains no current event-policy claim and is not copied from an official paper.
Need help choosing a next step? Scan the contact QR code below or contact Hanlin on WeChat. Send CCO-GIBBSTEMP-1108 and tell us your school year and question.
Keep the thermodynamic model explicit
Suppose a reaction has standard enthalpy change of +40.0 kilojoules per mole and standard entropy change of +100 joules per mole per kelvin. Treat these values as constant over the temperature range considered, with no phase changes.
Use standard Gibbs free-energy change = standard enthalpy change minus T times standard entropy change. Temperature is in kelvin. Converting enthalpy to joules gives 40,000 - 100T joules per mole; mixing 40 with the unconverted entropy term would be inconsistent.
Compare two temperatures and locate the crossing
At 298 kelvin, the standard free-energy change is 40,000 - 29,800 = +10,200 joules per mole, or +10.2 kilojoules per mole. At 500 kelvin, it is 40,000 - 50,000 = -10,000 joules per mole.
Within this simplified constant-property model, the standard value is zero at T = 40,000/100 = 400 kelvin. A positive entropy change makes the negative T-times-entropy contribution more important as temperature rises.
Distinguish a standard value from the actual mixture
The actual reaction free-energy change also depends on composition through the dimensionless reaction quotient Q: actual change = standard change + RT ln Q. For Q = 1, the extra term is zero, so the actual and standard values agree at that state.
A sign found for the standard value therefore cannot be assigned to every possible mixture. At the model's 400-kelvin crossing, the equilibrium constant is one; a different actual Q can still give a nonzero driving tendency.
Do not turn a direction statement into a speed claim
A negative reaction free-energy change indicates a thermodynamic tendency in the forward direction at the stated temperature, pressure and composition. It does not specify how fast a measurable change happens. Activation barriers and kinetics answer a different question.
For review, keep separate lines for units, temperature, standard versus actual conditions and rate. At equilibrium, zero reaction free-energy change also does not mean molecular processes have stopped. Share which of these distinctions caused difficulty when discussing a chemistry study question; the calculated sign alone is not the full explanation.
Continue reading: Canadian Chemistry Olympiad Practice: Choose a System Before Giving Heat a Sign.
Contact Hanlin
Planning a first attempt or reviewing a topic you find difficult? Scan the QR code and send CCO-GIBBSTEMP-1108. Include your school year, country or competition region, experience and the question you want to discuss.

On your phone, use the button or save the QR image and scan it within WeChat.

