During Canadian Chemistry Olympiad preparation, two statements can sound contradictory: a weak acid becomes more ionized after dilution, yet its hydronium concentration falls. They refer to different quantities. This original equilibrium exercise separates a percentage from a concentration. It contains no claim about current event dates, eligibility or an official paper.
Need help choosing a next step? Scan the contact QR code below or contact Hanlin on WeChat. Send CCO-IONIZATION-1107 and tell us your school year and question.
State the chemical model before using a shortcut
Consider a hypothetical monoprotic acid HA at fixed temperature, with Ka = 1.0 times 10 to the power -5. Use the usual dilute-solution concentration approximation, assume no added common ion, and neglect water's contribution to hydronium in the two cases considered.
For initial analytical acid concentration C, let the equilibrium hydronium concentration be x. The model gives [A-] = x and [HA] = C - x, so Ka = x squared divided by (C - x). The ionized fraction is x/C, not x alone.
Solve the equilibrium at the original concentration
At C = 0.100 mole per litre, solve x squared + Ka times x - Ka times C = 0. The physically allowed root is x = [square root of (Ka squared + 4KaC) - Ka]/2.
This gives x approximately 9.950 times 10 to the power -4 mole per litre. Dividing by 0.100 gives an ionized percentage of about 0.995%. Most of the analytical acid remains as HA in this model.
Dilute and calculate a new equilibrium
Dilute the acid one hundredfold to C = 0.00100 mole per litre at the same temperature. Solving the same quadratic gives x approximately 9.512 times 10 to the power -5 mole per litre. The hydronium concentration is lower, but x/C now corresponds to about 9.512% ionization.
Ka has not increased. The concentration and the fraction respond differently because the denominator C also falls. Simply dividing the old equilibrium hydronium concentration by one hundred would ignore the additional dissociation that occurs as equilibrium is re-established.
Check the approximation rather than hiding it
The common shortcut x approximately equals the square root of KaC assumes that x is small compared with C. The second calculation has nearly ten percent ionization, so keeping the quadratic avoids relying on that small-change approximation. Water ionization is still negligible at the calculated hydronium concentrations; this should not be assumed for arbitrarily extreme dilution.
For a clear review, make separate columns for C, x and 100x/C, including units only where appropriate. Share which column your explanation described. A larger percentage does not automatically mean a larger amount per litre, and the model assumptions remain part of the answer.
Continue reading: Canadian Chemistry Olympiad Practice: A Second Dilution Starts from the New Concentration.
Contact Hanlin
Planning a first attempt or reviewing a topic you find difficult? Scan the QR code and send CCO-IONIZATION-1107. Include your school year, country or competition region, experience and the question you want to discuss.

On your phone, use the button or save the QR image and scan it within WeChat.

