Colligative calculations require both a concentration definition and a particle-count model. Equal amounts of dissolved formula units do not necessarily produce equal numbers of independently moving solute particles. This original paper exercise compares idealised solutions, not measured laboratory results or an official CCO question.
Need help choosing a next step? Scan the contact QR code below or contact Hanlin on WeChat. Send CCO-FREEZING-DEPRESSION-1115 and tell us your school year and question.
Use molality with the right denominator
Let each solution contain 0.50 mole of its stated solute per kilogram of water. That is a molality of 0.50 mol/kg. The denominator is solvent mass, rather than total solution mass or solution volume. Two solutions described as 0.50 molar would provide a different concentration definition and could not simply be substituted into this calculation.
Specify the ideal particle factor
In the simplified model, dissolved glucose remains as individual molecules, so use a van t Hoff factor i = 1. Assume sodium chloride dissociates completely into independent sodium and chloride ions, giving i = 2. This is an ideal dilute-solution comparison. It is not a claim that every actual sodium chloride solution has an exactly measured factor of two.
Apply the freezing-point relation
Use a water freezing-point constant Kf = 1.86 kelvin kg/mol for this exercise. The depression magnitude is i Kf m. Glucose gives 1 times 1.86 times 0.50 = 0.93 kelvin. Ideal sodium chloride gives 2 times 1.86 times 0.50 = 1.86 kelvin. These values describe how far below the corresponding pure-solvent freezing point the ideal freezing point lies.
Check the sign and interpretation
The depression magnitude is positive, while the resulting freezing temperature is lower. Do not add 1.86 kelvin to the pure-water freezing temperature and describe that as a depression. Temperature differences have the same numerical size in kelvin and degrees Celsius, but absolute temperature expressions and concentration units still need careful treatment in other equations.
Keep the model distinct from real behaviour
Ion interactions, incomplete dissociation, association and solution concentration can alter observed colligative behaviour. The equation is useful only with assumptions and an appropriate effective particle factor. Also, equal masses of glucose and sodium chloride would not give equal formula-unit amounts because their molar masses differ. In a new problem, first identify solvent mass and solute moles, then justify the particle factor, and only then calculate the predicted temperature change.
Continue reading: Canadian Chemistry Olympiad Practice: A Second Halving Need Not Take the Same Time.
Contact Hanlin
Planning a first attempt or reviewing a topic you find difficult? Scan the QR code and send CCO-FREEZING-DEPRESSION-1115. Include your school year, country or competition region, experience and the question you want to discuss.

On your phone, use the button or save the QR image and scan it within WeChat.

