Canadian Chemistry Olympiad Practice: Similar Buffer pH Does Not Mean Similar Buffer Capacity

推荐

A buffer calculation asks two separate questions: what pH a mixture approximately has, and how much added acid or base it can absorb before that pH changes substantially. The same ratio can answer the first question while hiding a difference in the second. This original chemistry exercise uses a simplified weak-acid model. It does not reproduce a CCO problem or state participation rules.

Need help choosing a next step? Scan the contact QR code below or contact Hanlin on WeChat. Send CCO-BUFFER-DILUTION-1112 and tell us your school year and question.

Set up an appreciable weak conjugate pair

Suppose a 1.00 L solution contains approximately 0.020 mol of weak acid HA and 0.030 mol of its conjugate base A-. Take pKa as 4.76 and assume the usual concentration-based buffer approximation is appropriate at the stated temperature. We neglect activity corrections and the small changes caused by the acid equilibrium when first specifying these amounts. The base-to-acid ratio is 1.5.

Calculate the approximate starting pH

The Henderson-Hasselbalch expression gives pH approximately pKa + log10([A-]/[HA]). Thus pH is approximately 4.76 + log10(1.5), or 4.94. If pure water increases the volume tenfold without changing either amount, both concentrations divide by ten. Their ratio remains 1.5, so the same approximation predicts approximately the same pH. This does not mean dilution never affects a real buffer pH.

Compare equal volumes to discuss capacity

Compare a 100 mL portion of the original solution with a 100 mL portion of the tenfold-diluted solution. The first contains 0.0020 mol HA and 0.0030 mol A-. The diluted portion contains 0.00020 mol HA and 0.00030 mol A-. Their initial ratios are equal, but the diluted portion contains one tenth as much of each component. Equal starting pH has not made those inventories equal.

Add the same small amount of strong acid

Assume each portion receives 0.00010 mol of strong acid, with negligible volume change, and that it reacts with A- to form HA. The original portion then has 0.0029 mol A- and 0.0021 mol HA, giving an approximate pH of 4.90. The diluted portion has 0.00020 mol A- and 0.00030 mol HA, giving approximately 4.58. The same added amount produces a much larger pH change in the diluted portion.

Explain the comparison without overstating it

Capacity comparisons need a stated volume, concentration and size of added disturbance. The whole tenfold-expanded batch still contains the original total amounts; it is equal-sized portions that differ here. Very extensive dilution can invalidate the approximation as water autoionization and other effects become important. For a review answer, separate the initial ratio calculation, the reaction stoichiometry and the final ratio calculation. A buffer resists pH change; it does not hold pH perfectly fixed.

Continue reading: Canadian Chemistry Olympiad Practice: pH and Dilution Explained.

Contact Hanlin

Planning a first attempt or reviewing a topic you find difficult? Scan the QR code and send CCO-BUFFER-DILUTION-1112. Include your school year, country or competition region, experience and the question you want to discuss.

Scan to contact Hanlin on WeChat. Send CCO-BUFFER-DILUTION-1112.

Contact Hanlin on WeChat

On your phone, use the button or save the QR image and scan it within WeChat.

Official information and further reading: Source 1 Source 2

推荐
Online Customer Service
Contact Customer Service