The shortcut s = square root of Ksp works only under particular stoichiometric and solution assumptions. This original equilibrium exercise uses a hypothetical salt M2X to show why writing the dissolution equation must come first. It is not an official Canadian Chemistry Olympiad question or a laboratory procedure.
Need help choosing a next step? Scan the contact QR code below or contact Hanlin on WeChat. Send CCO-SOLUBILITY-1103 and tell us your school year and question.
Translate the formula into concentrations
Consider M2X(s) ⇌ 2M+(aq) + X2-(aq). Let its molar solubility be s in initially pure water. For every mole of salt that dissolves, two moles of M+ and one mole of X2- enter solution.
In our idealised model, [M+] = 2s and [X2-] = s. We assume no background ions, hydrolysis, complex formation or other reactions that would change these relationships.
Write the equilibrium expression carefully
The solid does not appear as a concentration factor. Using dimensionless activities approximated by concentration divided by the standard concentration c°, Ksp = ([M+]/c°)2([X2-]/c°) = 4(s/c°)3.
The coefficient 2 affects both the concentration 2s and the exponent in the expression. Missing either role changes the calculation. Here c° is 1 mol per litre, and the concentration approximation assumes sufficiently dilute ideal behaviour.
Calculate and substitute back
Let the hypothetical Ksp be 4 × 10-12. Then (s/c°)3 = 10-12, so s = 10-4 mol per litre. The ion concentrations are 2 × 10-4 and 10-4 mol per litre respectively.
Substitution gives (2 × 10-4)2(10-4) = 4 × 10-12 for the dimensionless concentration ratios. Taking a square root would describe neither this stoichiometry nor its ion balance.
Know when the simple model changes
If the solution already contains one of the ions, its initial concentration must be included. If acid-base chemistry or complex formation matters, a single dissolution equation may not determine the concentrations. Numerical Ksp comparisons between salts with different formulas also need care.
For a learning enquiry, share the balanced equation, initial solution conditions and your concentration expressions. That makes it possible to distinguish an algebra error from an incorrect chemical model.
Continue reading: Canadian Chemistry Olympiad Practice: Compare an Ion Product with Ksp.
Contact Hanlin
Planning a first attempt or reviewing a topic you find difficult? Scan the QR code and send CCO-SOLUBILITY-1103. Include your school year, country or competition region, experience and the question you want to discuss.

On your phone, use the button or save the QR image and scan it within WeChat.
Official information and further reading: Source 1

